The Chicago Cubs made a significant addition to their infield by securing Alex Bregman on a five-year contract this week, which has fueled speculation about potential trades involving infielder Matt Shaw or Nico Hoerner. Speaking at Bregman’s introductory press conference, Cubs president of baseball operations Jed Hoyer acknowledged an increase in trade inquiries about both players, according to Bruce Levine of 670 The Score. However, Hoyer indicated there is no immediate plan to trade either, and noted that Shaw might spend considerable time in the outfield this season to increase his opportunities in the lineup, as reported by Jesse Rogers of ESPN.
Impact of Bregman Signing on Infield Roles
Before Bregman’s arrival, the Cubs projected their infield alignment with Shaw at third base, Dansby Swanson at shortstop, Hoerner at second base, and Michael Busch at first base. The addition of Bregman at third base effectively limits Shaw’s chances for a full-time role at his familiar position. Shaw’s experience is primarily at third base but includes some stints at second and shortstop, which has partly sparked trade discussions centered on Hoerner. Given that Hoerner is approaching free agency, the Cubs might contemplate trading him to create room for Shaw at second base.
Comparing Hoerner’s Established Status to Shaw’s Emerging Role
Despite the trade rumors surrounding both players, Hoerner is a well-established major leaguer with a track record of consistent performance. Over the past four seasons, Hoerner has appeared in at least 135 games annually, boasting a combination of solid defensive skills, speed, and above-average hitting, resulting in at least 3.9 wins above replacement each year, according to FanGraphs. In contrast, Shaw, who debuted only last year, has participated in 126 big league games, compiling a modest batting line of .226/.295/.394 and a 93 wRC+. His second-half performance showed improvement with a .258/.317/.522 line across 205 plate appearances, translating to a 130 wRC+ in that smaller sample size.
Potential Trade Scenarios and Roster Strategies for 2026
The Cubs’ intention to contend in 2026—following their postseason appearance in 2025 and recent roster enhancements, including the signing of Bregman and acquisition of Edward Cabrera—makes downgrading the infield by replacing Hoerner with Shaw a risky proposition. While teams such as the Giants, Mariners, and Yankees have been linked to Hoerner, the Cubs appear inclined to retain him for the immediate future. Shaw is likely to serve as a versatile utility player this season, with the prospect of stepping into a more permanent role at second base if Hoerner departs after 2026 without a contract extension.
Shaw’s Outfield Prospects Despite Limited Experience
Although Shaw lacks professional experience in the outfield, his athleticism suggests potential for adaptation. Since being selected 13th overall in the 2023 draft, Shaw has primarily played third base and the middle infield in the minors. Last season in the majors, he spent almost all his time at third base, with only six innings at second base and no appearances at shortstop. Early in his college career, Shaw had some exposure to outfield play but has since focused on infield roles. Notably, his sprint speed ranked in the 90th percentile among major leaguers last year, indicating that his agility could support a transition to the outfield, provided the Cubs give him adequate reps during spring training to prepare him for that responsibility.
Advantages of Shaw’s Versatility for the Cubs’ Lineup
The Cubs value the flexibility of players who can cover multiple positions, especially given Shaw’s right-handed hitting and noticeable platoon splits during his rookie season. Against right-handed pitchers, Shaw posted a .218/.287/.362 slash line with an 82 wRC+, while with the platoon advantage his numbers improved to .250/.318/.490 and a 125 wRC+. The team projects several left-handed hitters in the regular lineup, including Pete Crow-Armstrong in center field, Busch at first base, and Moisés Ballesteros likely sharing catching duties and serving as the designated hitter. Each of these players has performed better against right-handed pitching. Additionally, switch-hitter Ian Happ has historically produced more effectively as a lefty batter. Shaw’s presence could offer valuable lineup flexibility depending on matchups.
Defensive Considerations and Outfield Depth
The role of Seiya Suzuki also factors into the Cubs’ defensive plans in the outfield. Last year, Suzuki mainly served as the designated hitter, but with Kyle Tucker’s departure, he is expected to take on more time in the field. Defensive metrics like Outs Above Average and Defensive Runs Saved have rated Suzuki negatively in his career, which may lead the Cubs to substitute him defensively late in games. Having an additional outfield option capable of reliable play could help address this weakness and provide managerial flexibility.
Roster Health and Adaptability Highlight Need for Versatile Players
Injury risks and shifting team needs underscore the value of versatility. If Shaw can competently play the outfield, the Cubs will have greater freedom to shuffle the lineup depending on health and strategic matchups. The bench currently includes backup catcher Miguel Amaya, first baseman Tyler Austin, utility players Shaw, and outfielder Justin Dean, the latter known for strong defense and baserunning but with questions surrounding his hitting ability. Dean also remains optionable, which adds to roster maneuverability.
Shaw’s Development and Importance of Playing Time
Securing consistent playing time is crucial for Shaw’s development, considering he only reached the majors last year and showed signs of progress as the season advanced. A part-time role with limited opportunities could hinder his long-term growth, especially as the Cubs anticipate Shaw eventually succeeding Hoerner at second base. Providing Shaw with 400 to 600 plate appearances, even without a defined starting position, would benefit both the player and the organization by accelerating his readiness and contributing to the team’s competitiveness.
https://twitter.com/MLBBruceLevine/status/2011866292102267334
https://twitter.com/JesseRogersESPN/status/2011877675653349619
