Pickleball Noise Sparks Controversy: Nantucket, the picturesque island off the Massachusetts coast, is the latest community to grapple with pickleball’s growing popularity—and its noise. Town officials are considering a zoning bylaw amendment to prohibit the construction of pickleball courts in all zoning districts on the island, sparking debate among residents.
The proposed regulation responds to complaints about the sport’s distinct “thwacking” sound, which some argue disrupts the tranquility of quiet neighborhoods. While pickleball has surged in popularity as a low-impact, social activity, particularly among those over 50, its noise has led to conflicts in communities nationwide.
View this post on Instagram
Pickleball Noise: A Growing Concern
Pickleball combines elements of tennis, badminton, and ping-pong, played with a small plastic ball that creates a louder sound than traditional racquet sports. The game has become a staple on indoor and outdoor pickleball courts, but the noise has sparked disputes in various towns.
Communities in Florida and even New York City have implemented bans or restrictions to address concerns. Nantucket’s proposal, however, stands out for its potential scope, as it seeks to limit court construction island-wide.
The Proposed Regulation
The amendment, introduced at a government meeting, would not impact existing pickleball courts but would restrict new ones from being built in any zoning district on the island.
Planning Board Chair Dave Iverson has suggested a more moderate approach, advocating for regulations that control court placement rather than an outright ban.
“This shouldn’t be about banning pickleball but finding a balance that preserves the character of our neighborhoods,” Iverson said.
The proposal will be discussed further at the annual Town Meeting, where residents will weigh in.
Mixed Reactions from Residents
News of the proposed amendment has generated strong reactions. Some residents see the measure as excessive regulation of a beloved activity that promotes fitness and social interaction. Others, however, support the idea of limiting pickleball courts to reduce noise in residential areas.
On social media, reactions ranged from amusement to frustration. While one commenter dismissed the proposal as an “early April Fool’s joke,” others questioned whether the town should regulate a recreational activity so heavily.
What’s Next for Pickleball on Nantucket?
For now, Nantucketers can continue enjoying pickleball matches, but the sport’s future on the island remains uncertain. Whether through a complete ban or selective regulation, the decision could set an example for how other communities address similar challenges.
As the sport continues to grow, local governments may need to find innovative ways to balance the demand for pickleball courts with the concerns of those who value peace and quiet.
News in Brief: Pickleball Noise Sparks Controversy
Nantucket is considering a zoning bylaw amendment to ban new pickleball courts across the island due to noise complaints.
Existing courts would remain unaffected. The proposal will be discussed further at the annual Town Meeting, highlighting ongoing debates over balancing recreational activities with neighborhood tranquility.
ALSO READ: New Pickleball Courts in Fillmore Enhance Local Sports Facilities