Country Club Sues City Over Pickleball Court Ban: Greenbriar Hills Country Club has filed a lawsuit against the City of Kirkwood, challenging restrictions that have kept its newly built pickleball courts closed. The country club claims that city-imposed conditions, including a noise study requirement, violated state laws and is seeking a court ruling to invalidate the restrictions.
Pickleball Court Plans and City Approval
In November 2022, Greenbriar Hills submitted plans to build new pickleball courts and expand its swimming pool. Kirkwood’s Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval, and in January 2023, the City Council gave its approval—with one key condition.
The courts could only open if a post-construction noise study confirmed that sound levels complied with St. Louis County’s noise ordinance.
Noise Study and Court Closure
Greenbriar Hills proceeded with construction, knowing the courts couldn’t be used unless they passed the noise test. However, an October 2023 study found that noise levels exceeded legal limits, preventing the courts from opening.
Now, more than two years after approval, the courts remain unused.
Legal Challenge Against the City
In the lawsuit, Greenbriar Hills argues that the city’s condition is vague, as noise violations can depend on changing ambient conditions.
The lawsuit further claims that Kirkwood bypassed legal procedures by setting the noise condition as a resolution rather than an ordinance, which would require a formal legal process under Missouri’s zoning laws.
Additionally, the country club alleges that the city unlawfully delegated enforcement power to a private entity instead of an official government body like the St. Louis County Department of Health.
Seeking a Court Ruling
Greenbriar Hills is asking the court for a writ of mandamus, a legal order that would invalidate the city’s conditions and allow the pickleball courts to open as originally planned.
The case raises broader questions about zoning authority, noise regulations, and municipal decision-making. The court’s ruling could impact future development projects and how cities regulate community spaces.
News in Brief: Country Club Sues City Over Pickleball Court Ban
Greenbriar Hills Country Club is suing Kirkwood over conditions preventing its new pickleball courts from opening. The lawsuit challenges the legality of city-imposed noise regulations, arguing they violate Missouri zoning laws. The club seeks a court ruling to overturn the restrictions, which could have wider implications for zoning and city governance.
ALSO READ: New Pickleball Courts Coming to Gulf Breeze as Part of Major Upgrades