San Francisco’s Pickleball and Tennis Conflict: San Francisco’s tennis and pickleball communities are at a standstill. Tensions have erupted into acts of vandalism and heated confrontations as both sports compete for the limited court space. The proposed solution? A clear demarcation: separate courts for tennis and pickleball to prevent disputes over usage.
A Proposal for Peaceful Coexistence
Mary Hickey, a USA Pickleball ambassador, has become a leading voice in this movement. “We will not go on the tennis courts, and they will not go on the pickleball courts, and we will all say ‘hi’ as we pass each other,” Hickey said during an interview with the Chronicle. Hickey, who promotes pickleball through free clinics at the Presidio Wall every Tuesday, is one of the many advocates pushing for this separation.
The Plan: Dedicated Courts
The proposal, now up for a vote, suggests establishing four permanent pickleball courts next to a single tennis court. This challenges the Recreation and Parks Department’s current strategy of shared courts, which has proven problematic as the popularity of pickleball continues to soar. Pickleball requires a different setup than tennis, often involving players bringing their nets and equipment.
Official Acknowledgement and Challenges
Phil Ginsburg, the General Manager of Rec and Parks, acknowledged the proposal’s thoughtfulness. “We normally don’t respond to public comment, but I did want to acknowledge the good faith, creative idea about using space to resolve user conflicts, which has been a big challenge with these sports that compete for the same court time,” Ginsburg said. However, he noted that the existing plan for shared courts might be difficult to alter due to existing contracts. Despite this, he encouraged collaboration between pickleball players and Rec and Parks’ tennis and pickleball working group to find a viable solution.
Incidents and Tensions
The conflict over court usage has not been without significant incidents. Prior to a water main rupture in August 2021, which caused $20 million in damages and led to the closure of Stern Grove’s facilities, tennis and pickleball players shared the courts. The courts are set to reopen with a hybrid model, which Hickey and others criticized for resulting in costly replacements of rolling nets due to vandalism and altercations.
During a recent commission meeting, pickleball enthusiasts presented a detailed PowerPoint outlining their separate-court plan, citing multiple incidents of hostility over the past 17 months. These included the theft of six pickleball nets from Rossi Park and vandals slashing a net at Rossi pickleball courts on the same day the thefts occurred. Vandals also cut nets in half at Moscone Recreation Center and threw nets over the fence at Buena Vista Park.
Peter Mueller, a prominent pickleball community advocate, expressed frustration over these incidents. “If you go to a place one day, and return the next day and the nets are slashed, it’s reasonable to assume they were vandalized,” Mueller said. A particularly intense incident on July 4 at Rossi Park saw tennis players aggressively moving their nets onto a court during a pickleball game, escalating to shouting and a physical altercation.
Advocacy and Hope
Despite these challenges, advocates like Peter Mueller and Lilian Murphy remain hopeful. Murphy emphasized the mutual desire for dedicated courts. “The common desire for the pickleball and tennis communities are dedicated-line courts,” Murphy said. “Tension is eliminated, all-day play is accessible, clear boundaries are set for recreational play.” She acknowledged the additional costs and challenges the proposed revision might pose for Rec and Parks, suggesting “partnership funding” from the pickleball community as a solution.
A Vision for the Future
As the debate continues, the proposed solution of separate courts could pave the way for a harmonious coexistence. The push for separate but equal facilities might just be the key to ensuring sports can flourish without conflict, providing dedicated spaces where enthusiasts can enjoy their games in peace.
News in Brief: San Francisco’s Pickleball and Tennis Conflict
San Francisco’s ongoing pickleball and tennis conflict might be resolved with a new proposal advocating for separate courts for each sport. Mary Hickey, a USA Pickleball ambassador, supports this plan, which would establish four permanent pickleball courts next to a tennis court, challenging the current dual-purpose court strategy.
Phil Ginsburg, General Manager of Rec and Parks, acknowledges the idea but notes potential contractual obstacles. Advocates like Peter Mueller and Lilian Murphy emphasize the need for dedicated courts to reduce tensions and propose “partnership funding” to cover costs. The plan aims for harmonious coexistence, allowing both sports to thrive without conflict.
Also Read: Anna Bright’s Unexpected Journey with St. Louis Shock in MLP
