Hunter Park Pickleball Controversy: An upcoming court hearing on December 18 could significantly impact pickleball play at Hunter Park in Newport, Rhode Island. The lawsuit filed by neighbors Mona Barberas and Warren Garner accuses the city of creating excessive noise and public nuisance, calling for the closure of pickleball courts at Hunter Park. The case highlights broader challenges cities face as the sport grows in popularity.
The Complaint: Noise and Disruption
The lawsuit, filed nearly a year ago in Newport County Superior Court, seeks to declare pickleball at Hunter Park a public and private nuisance. Plaintiffs claim the noise disrupts daily life, making it impossible to read, host gatherings, or work from home. The suit alleges the city unlawfully repurposed tennis courts for pickleball, citing noise levels exceeding city thresholds.
“The noise has prevented plaintiffs from reading in peace, having conversations with guests, resting during the day, sitting or walking in their gardens, having holiday or social daytime gatherings and performing professional work in the home, such as phone calls and video conferences.” – (complaint)
Despite the city posting restricted pickleball hours and warnings at Hunter Park, the complaint argues these measures have done little to mitigate the issue.
“Seriously! Please don’t play pickleball outside of these times or risk pickleball not being allowed on these courts for good.” – (the city)
A Growing National Controversy
The Newport case reflects similar conflicts across the U.S., including in Falmouth, Massachusetts, and Fairfax County, Virginia, where pickleball’s rise has clashed with community noise standards. Recent disputes have led to court settlements, re-lining of courts for tennis, and even player protests.
To address such concerns, companies are now producing quieter paddles, with USA Pickleball certifying its first “quiet” racket last year. However, these innovations have yet to resolve disputes like Newport’s, where the courts remain a flashpoint for neighborhood tensions.
Policy Changes and New Venues
In response to noise complaints, Newport’s Tree and Open Space Commission recommended adjusting pickleball hours at Hunter and Vernon parks, a move approved by the City Council in November. Yet, residents near Hunter Park argue these changes fall short.
Meanwhile, alternative indoor options are emerging. The Newport Pickleball Club, opening in January, will feature 11 indoor courts and a sports bar, aiming to provide a quieter environment for enthusiasts. Co-owner John Theberge said the new facility was designed to replicate outdoor play conditions, addressing player preferences and community concerns.
News in Brief: Hunter Park Pickleball Controversy
Newport’s ongoing legal battle over pickleball noise at Hunter Park shows a growing national tension between the sport’s popularity and its community impact. Neighbors have sued to shut down the courts, citing excessive noise and disruption.
While the city implemented restricted playing hours and offers indoor alternatives, tensions remain unresolved. A hearing on December 18 will determine the sport’s future at Hunter Park, with potential implications for public pickleball courts across Newport.
ALSO READ: Florida Senator Proposes Bill to Halt Pickleball Court Development in State Parks