Pickleball Overtaking Tennis as the Healthier Choice: A recent Reddit debate has reignited a spirited discussion in the sports world about which game can truly be called the “world’s healthiest sport.” The debate was sparked by a sign prominently displayed at the US Open, where tennis officials proclaimed the sport’s health benefits—a claim that some saw as a thinly-veiled response to the rising popularity of pickleball.
While tennis has long been celebrated for its physical benefits, a recent study has touted racket sports, including pickleball, as among the top activities for extending life expectancy. That report, coupled with pickleball’s surge in popularity, seems to have prompted tennis officials to dig in and defend their territory.
Clashing Cultures
The online conversation quickly turned to the cultural differences between tennis and pickleball. Tennis enthusiasts lamented the “obnoxious” noise from pickleball courts and accused the sport of eroding tennis infrastructure. Some tennis advocates, frustrated by pickleball’s rise, are now pushing for “red ball tennis”—a form of tennis played with slower balls on smaller courts, resembling pickleball’s setup. Critics argue this is a thinly-veiled attempt to reclaim courts lost to pickleball players.
Meanwhile, some countries are embracing pickleball’s rise. At the French Open, organizers even set up pickleball courts for fans to try out, suggesting a more inclusive approach to the sport.
Different Experiences
Reddit users noted how tennis and pickleball offer different playing experiences, with a key difference being accessibility. One commenter remarked that finding a tennis partner often requires extensive planning, whereas with pickleball, players can simply show up to open play sessions.
Another player shared their struggles finding partners for tennis, which led them to quit the sport. “If it were as easy to pick up doubles tennis as it is pickleball, I’d probably play both,” they wrote.
Others cited the prohibitive costs of tennis club memberships and court rentals, contrasting that with the ease of access to multiple pickleball facilities in their area. “USTA could have partnered with pickleball,” another user noted, “but now it’s too late.”
Room for Both Sports
While some expressed frustration over tennis’s reaction to pickleball’s growth, others saw a place for both sports to coexist. “Plenty of people play and love both,” wrote one user. Yet, many were critical of the USTA’s approach, accusing the organization of being overly defensive and unwilling to embrace a growing sport that shares common ground with tennis.
A few comments called the push for “red ball tennis” a futile effort. “The red ball video is pathetic—just a different name for kids’ mini tennis,” one user wrote.
Health Benefits and Risks
Some contributors praised pickleball for being a lifelong sport that promotes fitness, particularly for those who may have been sedentary. “Pickleball, if played correctly, is also great for the brain,” one user observed. However, others warned of injuries due to lack of preparation, urging players to stretch and use proper technique to avoid common pitfalls like falls and tears.
A New Era for Racket Sports?
For some, the debate seemed less about choosing sides and more about embracing the fact that different sports meet different needs. As one user succinctly put it: “Tennis is more fun to watch, but I’ll play pickleball because of availability, the social aspect, and it being easier on the body.”
Whether you call it “paddle tennis” or “mini-tennis,” it’s clear that pickleball is here to stay. As for the name itself, one commenter suggested, “The sport needs a name change. It makes me giggle when I hear it.”
With both sports offering unique benefits, perhaps the future isn’t about one sport versus the other but about a new era where racket sports—tennis, pickleball, or otherwise—find common ground in promoting health and community.
News in Brief: Pickleball Overtaking Tennis as the Healthier Choice
A Reddit debate reignited discussion on which sport is the “world’s healthiest,” sparked by a US Open sign promoting tennis’s health benefits in response to pickleball’s rising popularity. Tennis fans criticized pickleball’s noise and impact on courts, while others embraced its accessibility and lower costs. Some users noted the struggles of finding tennis partners, contrasting it with pickleball’s open play sessions. While tensions exist, many believe both sports can coexist, each offering unique health benefits. The debate highlights differences in culture, accessibility, and the future of racket sports as both tennis and pickleball continue to grow.
ALSO READ: Pickleball’s Too-Familiar Scenes: Video Highlights Unpredictability in Pickleball
