Ezequiel Garay, a former Real Madrid defender and Argentina international, holds a unique perspective on the Messi GOAT debate perspective, having played alongside both Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo. His time at Madrid between 2008 and 2011 gave him a close-up view of Ronaldo’s rise as he became the club’s all-time leading scorer with 450 goals in 438 appearances. Additionally, Garay represented Argentina 32 times, making his senior debut in 2007 after helping the nation win the U20 World Cup alongside Messi and Sergio Aguero.
Garay’s Clear Stance in the GOAT Discussion
Asked to weigh in on the enduring debate over who is the greatest footballer of all time, Garay did not hesitate. Speaking to DAZN, the 39-year-old stated,
“No, (Ronaldo is not the best player I’ve ever played with). Number one is Leo and number two is Cristiano, without a doubt. They are two very different players, but the one who has surprised me the most is Leo. I have been fortunate enough to play with both of them, and Leo is something else.”
While emphasizing Messi’s superiority in what he called “pure football terms,” Garay acknowledged Ronaldo’s extraordinary discipline and relentless dedication, which underpinned his remarkable success throughout his career.
Ronaldo’s Legendary Work Ethic Confirmed by Peers
Ronaldo’s unmatched drive to excel has been well documented over his lengthy and record-breaking career. Carlos Tevez, another player who has shared dressing rooms with both Ronaldo and Messi, has offered anecdotes that highlight Ronaldo’s commitment.
Tevez reflected on his time with Ronaldo at Manchester United, saying,
If we trained at nine in the morning, you arrived at eight in the morning, he was already there. At half past seven, he was already there. I mean, when can you fool this guy? One day I arrived at six in the morning to grab him and he was already there. Half asleep but he was there.
Garay supported that view from his perspective, having witnessed Ronaldo’s move from Old Trafford to Real Madrid in 2009. He said,
The story that Carlitos Tevez always tells is true. He’s the first to arrive at 6 am and the last to leave. He starts his routine, his gym session, his warm-up, his physio… all that to always be in the best condition.
Despite these lauded traits, both Tevez and Garay regard Messi as the greater talent. Tevez pointed out the contrast in their approaches, stating,
Cristiano is totally different to Messi. When Leo was starting, he didn’t gym. Cristiano was there in the morning, afternoon and evening, Leo was always with the ball. Cristiano had to work and prepare himself to be the best, it comes natural for Leo.
Potential Reunion of Football Icons in MLS Looms
Both Messi and Ronaldo continue to compete at a high level as their careers enter their twilight years. Ronaldo is currently under contract with Saudi Pro League club Al-Nassr until 2027, while Messi has signed with MLS champions Inter Miami through 2028.
With both players expected to represent their countries—Portugal and Argentina—in this summer’s World Cup, speculation has intensified over a possible reunion in Major League Soccer. Reports have emerged questioning Ronaldo’s future at Al-Nassr after recent incidents suggesting dissatisfaction, fuelling hopes that fans might witness these two legends join forces in the United States.
The Enduring Impact of the Messi and Ronaldo Rivalry
The ongoing debate over who stands as the greatest player of all time remains one of football’s most passionate discussions. Insights from Garay, who has an insider’s viewpoint on both players’ careers and qualities, reinforce Messi’s standing in this debate while not diminishing Ronaldo’s remarkable achievements grounded in hard work and determination.
As both icons continue to chase further accolades on the world stage and in their current leagues, their legacies and influence on future generations remain unparalleled. Whether a high-profile reunion materializes in MLS or both culminate their careers on international platforms, the Messi GOAT debate perspective is certain to stay a vibrant topic among fans and experts alike.
¿Es Cristiano Ronaldo el mejor jugador con el que ha jugado Garay?
💭 "No. El '1' Leo Messi y el '2' Cristiano. Leo es otra cosa" #LADAZONETA pic.twitter.com/OI4tHOirj6
— DAZN Fútbol (@DAZNFutbol) February 2, 2026
