Nick Herbig, a promising edge defender from the Steelers’ 2023 draft class, is now eligible for a contract extension. Despite standing out as an effective pass rusher, his path to a starting role remains uncertain due to the depth at his position. Questions arise about whether Herbig will commit to an extension or explore free agency, especially as the team’s roster currently limits his opportunity.
Herbig’s Performance and Position on the Depth Chart
Selected in the fourth round of the 2023 NFL Draft, Herbig has made the most of his limited playing time by tallying 16 sacks across 11 starts, mostly in rotational roles. He has shown notable impact as a pass rusher and collected an impressive array of stats including forced fumbles and tackles for loss. However, his potential starting chances are blocked by established players T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith, raising concerns about his upward mobility within the Steelers’ defense.
Expert Opinions on Herbig’s Future with the Steelers
Sports analyst Ray Fittipaldo has voiced skepticism about Herbig’s long-term place on Pittsburgh’s roster. He remarked,
“That’s the unknown question: are all those guys back?”
regarding the Steelers’ 2023 draft class. Fittipaldo went further stating,
“Nick [Herbig]’s good enough to start somewhere, probably just not here. If they can get it done, yeah, but I think he’s a guy who’s probably gonna want to test free agency. He might be the one to tell them, ‘Hey, I’m gonna play this out and I might want to test the free agent waters a year from now’.”
Contract Extensions Across the Steelers’ 2023 Draft Class
Among the seven players drafted by Pittsburgh in 2023, all remain with the team, many securing starting roles. While first-round pick Broderick Jones faces competition for his spot, other key players like Joey Porter Jr. and Keeanu Benton are largely expected to sign new contracts this offseason. Tight end Darnell Washington is also a candidate for an extension if terms are agreeable. Herbig’s situation stands apart because he lacks a clear starting role despite his evident talent.
Negotiation Challenges and Potential Contract Terms for Herbig
Deciding what Herbig’s market value should be is complicated by his current role and the Steelers’ roster structure. Without plans to replace Watt or Highsmith, the team’s starting edge positions remain locked. Herbig might consider a short-term deal, perhaps two years long, as a middle ground. At 27 years old, timing is crucial since delaying a big contract could affect his prime earning years. Meanwhile, unforeseen changes such as Watt’s retirement could alter Herbig’s prospects ahead.
Herbig’s Impact and Reasons to Consider an Extension
The Steelers would likely prioritize re-signing Herbig given his production, highlighted by 16 sacks, 32 quarterback hits, 23 tackles for loss, nine forced fumbles, and an interception. His consistent disruptive play, particularly his rare feat of multiple forced fumbles in three straight seasons, distinguishes him among rotational defenders. This demonstrates his potential as a valuable asset moving forward.
Factors Influencing Herbig’s Decision to Stay or Test Free Agency
Despite his contributions, Herbig faces tough choices. Accepting an extension limits his flexibility but can offer financial security, especially if injury guarantees are substantial. Otherwise, betting on himself by finishing his rookie contract and entering unrestricted free agency might yield a more lucrative deal. Franchise tag options appear unlikely due to their high cost unless he is projected as a starter, providing him with a clearer path to free agency.
The Broader Significance of Herbig’s Contract Outcome
Herbig’s decision will affect both his career trajectory and the Steelers’ defensive plans. Securing his talent in Pittsburgh would strengthen the team’s edge rush depth, but forcing a premature contract might lead to dissatisfaction. Conversely, if Herbig opts to test the open market, the Steelers must be prepared for potential gaps in their pass-rushing lineup or consider moving established starters. His case underscores the balancing act teams and players face between opportunity, timing, and value in contract negotiations.
