The Chicago Bears are preparing for a crucial week as the NFL scouting combine takes place in Indianapolis, offering a prime opportunity to identify potential Jaquan Brisker replacements Bears need to fill key defensive gaps. With Brisker’s future in Chicago uncertain and All-Pro safety Kevin Byard also entering free agency, the Bears face pressing decisions on how to strengthen their secondary.
Emmanuel McNeil-Warren Offers Versatility and Strong Run Defense
With the likely absence of a trade-up for Ohio State’s Caleb Downs—widely regarded as the top safety prospect—the Bears may turn their attention to Emmanuel McNeil-Warren from Toledo. Projected as a late first-round or early second-round pick, McNeil-Warren’s appeal lies in his capacity against the run. Over 848 run defense snaps, he has recorded 56 run stops and accumulated 148 tackles in four seasons, according to Pro Football Focus.
While his 10.9% missed tackle rate is higher than Brisker’s 5.6% last year, it aligns closely with Brisker’s career figure of 10.2%. McNeil-Warren’s versatility on the field adds to his value; last season, he played 401 snaps close to the line of scrimmage, 198 snaps as a deep safety, and 33 snaps in the slot cornerback role. Though some analysts, including NFL.com’s Lance Zierlein, have suggested coverage limitations, McNeil-Warren still managed six catches allowed for 116 yards and a touchdown, while securing two interceptions and five pass breakups from 15 targets.
Considering Brisker’s own struggles in coverage—allowing 36 receptions for 374 yards and four touchdowns—the Bears might find McNeil-Warren a worthy candidate if he demonstrates the necessary athleticism and intangibles during the combine, either with their 25th overall pick or through a strategic trade-up from the 57th pick.
Dillon Thieneman Brings Defensive Intelligence and Tackling Prowess
Dillon Thieneman, ranked 36th by NFL Mock Draft Database’s consensus board, could provide the Bears with a smart and adaptable presence in the secondary reminiscent of Brisker’s role. Although Brisker had just four interceptions in Chicago, his responsibility for pre-snap adjustments and leadership in the secondary was a key aspect of his game. Thieneman projects as a player who might fill that role under defensive coordinator Dennis Allen.
Throughout three collegiate seasons at Purdue and Oregon, Thieneman amassed 306 total tackles, including 188 solo stops. His coverage skills are notable, with eight career interceptions—six of which came during his freshman year at Purdue. Zierlein characterized him as
“an extension of his defensive coordinator,”
highlighting his football IQ and ability to direct teammates.
Thieneman also holds strength against the run, with 30 run stops during his single Oregon season, and has improved his missed tackle rate consistently from 13.1% as a freshman to 8.3% most recently. Performance at the combine will likely influence how high his draft value climbs, which could benefit the Bears if they pursue a reliable and cerebral safety replacement.
Bud Clark Could Emerge as a Stealthy Ball-Hawking Option
While not projected as a first-round pick, Bud Clark of TCU has been gaining attention after a standout showing at the Senior Bowl, which could elevate his draft position significantly. Currently ranked 104th on the consensus big board, Clark displayed notable coverage skills and athleticism that captured NFL scouts’ interest earlier this month.
“He flew around the field, showing sticky man-coverage ability during one-on-one drills, and came downhill during team sessions to break up a pass,”
noted B/R’s NFL scouts at the Senior Bowl, as reported by Gary Davenport. Chicago has been mentioned as an ideal landing spot for Clark.
Lance Zierlein further compared Clark’s coverage capability to Kerby Joseph, given Clark’s knack for intercepting passes—he secured 15 interceptions during his time with the Horned Frogs. However, Clark’s tackling may raise some concerns, with a 14.8% missed tackle rate and only 13 run stops in his final college season. Still, his coverage prowess might provide the Bears with a reliable ball-hawking safety alongside Byard if the veteran re-signs or as a developmental piece if Brisker departs.
Implications for the Bears’ Secondary and Upcoming Decisions
As Chicago navigates an uncertain offseason with major decisions looming around Jaquan Brisker and Kevin Byard, the NFL combine represents a critical point for scouting safety talent. Identifying a replacement who can match Brisker’s contributions, particularly in tackling and defensive communication, will be essential for maintaining the Bears’ recent success in the NFC North.
The performances of Emmanuel McNeil-Warren, Dillon Thieneman, and Bud Clark over the next week may significantly influence Chicago’s draft strategy. Whether the Bears opt for a first-round investment or target a sleeper with growth potential, securing the right player will determine how well the team can sustain its defensive strengths moving forward into free agency and the NFL Draft.
