Cole Holcomb, an inside linebacker with seven years of experience, has entered unrestricted free agency following the 2024 NFL season. At 29 years old, approaching 30 in July, Holcomb’s recent return to the field is notable given his severe knee injury two years ago that sidelined him for the entire previous season. His ability to play during the 2024 campaign stands as a significant milestone, though questions remain about his ongoing role and potential impact.
Performance and Role During the 2024 Season
Originally signing a three-year contract with the Steelers in 2023, Holcomb struggled to reclaim his starting position after his injury. While initially relegated to an emergency reserve role, his playing time increased modestly as the season progressed. Holcomb logged under 200 defensive snaps, seeing limited action behind inside linebacker Patrick Queen and backups Payton Wilson and Malik Harrison. However, he contributed significantly on special teams, with 161 snaps—a high mark since his rookie year.
During 14 games and three starts, Holcomb recorded 37 tackles and forced one fumble. Although he faced criticism for missed tackles, the time away from football likely affected his sharpness and overall performance. Holcomb’s role gradually shifted from a defensive starter to more of a depth and special teams player throughout the season.
Potential Directions in Free Agency
As Holcomb approaches free agency, the uncertainty surrounding his future grows especially in light of the Steelers’ evolving coaching staff. At present, inside linebackers coach Scott McCurley is one of only two Steelers coaches retained heading into the new season. Holcomb’s limited experience under McCurley—one season—means the perspectives of this coach, along with those of new head coach Mike McCarthy, could heavily influence contract decisions.
McCurley’s relationship with Mike McCarthy might sway the organization’s decision on Holcomb’s value. If seen as a cost-effective alternative to Malik Harrison, who received a lucrative contract last year, Holcomb’s continued presence would offer depth and special teams reliability. Recognizing that Holcomb can perform again after his injury may position him as a viable option in the Steelers’ linebacker rotation.
Wider Free Agency Environment for the Steelers
The Steelers face a broad free agency landscape in 2025, yet few names on the roster appear indispensable. Aaron Rodgers remains the clear exception, with public statements indicating the team’s desire to retain him. Other free agents such as Kenneth Gainwell and Isaac Seumalo represent important contributors but are not urgent retaining priorities. The quarterback situation remains central to offseason strategy, with the organization unlikely to revisit past decisions like the release of Mason Rudolph.
New leadership and nearly an entirely revamped coaching staff herald an offseason filled with unpredictability. Between February and March, the Steelers could pursue substantial roster changes, such as surprising cuts, trades, or an aggressive retooling of player roles, particularly on defense where Holcomb’s position falls.
Implications for Cole Holcomb and the Steelers’ Future
Cole Holcomb’s free agency status places him at a crossroads, with the Steelers weighing his recent recovery, past contributions, and potential affordability against the demands of a new coaching era. Whether Holcomb remains part of Pittsburgh’s future linebacking corps or becomes a casualty of roster turnover hinges on evaluations from the retained coaching staff and the team’s broader rebuilding strategy. His ability to contribute on special teams may improve his chances of retention, but the uncertainty of evaluation under new leadership leaves his path unresolved as the offseason unfolds.
