Florida’s Great Outdoors Initiative Sparks Controversy: Florida’s Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) disclosed a controversial plan Monday aimed at enhancing state parks with new amenities, including golf courses, pickleball courts, and expanded lodging options. Dubbed the “Great Outdoors Initiative,” the proposal seeks to increase public access and recreational opportunities but has ignited widespread criticism from environmentalists and some lawmakers.
“In addition to increasing the number of campsites, cabins and lodges on park property, the initiative will increase the number of outdoor recreation opportunities available at Florida’s state parks, including pickleball, disc golf, golf and paddling.” – (dep)
The initiative includes plans for several state parks across South Florida, potentially impacting Dr. Von D. Mizell-Eula Johnson State Park in Dania Beach, Jonathan Dickinson State Park in Hobe Sound, and Oleta River State Park in North Miami Beach. According to the DEP, the project aims to “expand public access, increase outdoor activities, and provide new lodging options” at these parks.
Jonathan Dickinson State Park, which spans 10,500 acres, is proposed to host three golf courses—two with 18 holes and one with nine. This plan has drawn sharp criticism from environmental advocates, who argue that it threatens some of the region’s last remaining scrub habitat, which is critical for local wildlife, including the threatened Florida scrub jay. The park’s existing wilderness hiking and biking trails, as well as the Hobe Mountain boardwalk and observation tower, could also face closures due to the proposed developments.
“We are considering the addition of golf — one of our nation’s most popular sports — in a way that will minimize habitat impacts and leverage already-disturbed areas.” – (dep)
The DEP has stated that it will consider the addition of golf in a way that minimizes habitat impacts, emphasizing that the park is already surrounded by numerous golf courses. However, critics like Linda Smithe from the Sierra Club Loxahatchee Group argue that the plan could lead to significant environmental degradation, describing the potential loss of pristine scrubland as a “crime.”
“Destroying some of the last pristine scrub land in Southeast Florida would be a crime.” – (Smithe)
Julie Wraithmell, executive director of Audubon Florida, highlights the rarity and ecological importance of scrub habitat, which supports several endangered species. The Florida scrub-jay, in particular, is a key species that could be adversely affected by the proposed development. Wraithmell expressed concern that such habitat destruction would leave the birds with nowhere else to go.
The DEP also proposes adding up to four pickleball courts at Dr. Von D. Mizell-Eula Johnson State Park and Oleta River State Park, which would be set amidst mangrove waterways and bird habitats. While pickleball is a popular and growing sport, the intrusion into sensitive natural areas has sparked further discontent among residents and environmentalists.
“Dr. Von. D Mizell-Eula Johnson State Park is in the heart of one of Florida’s busiest regions. Converting an underutilized paved area to pickleball courts will benefit both locals & out-of-town visitors.” – (dep)
Rep. Peggy Gossett-Seidman, R-Highland Beach, has voiced skepticism about the initiative. She suggests that while the proposal may aim to boost local employment and recreational opportunities, it seems contradictory to the DEP’s preservation efforts. Gossett-Seidman’s concerns echo the sentiments of many who have expressed shock and dismay at the plan, with several public comments and letters urging a reevaluation.
“Find out why this came about, what’s behind it, and who thought of turning our parks into what normally is handled by county and municipalities.” – (Gossett-Seidman)
The DEP has scheduled public meetings for August 27 across the eight affected counties to discuss the initiative. A petition titled “Protect Jonathan Dickinson State Park: Stop the Golf Courses!” had garnered over 60,000 signatures by Thursday afternoon, and Audubon Florida has mobilized efforts to submit letters to Governor Ron DeSantis urging him to abandon the proposal.
Residents, including Lisa Hoffmeyer from Hollywood, have voiced their opposition, stating that the parks should remain more passive and less developed. Allie Hartmann from Friends of the Everglades echoed this sentiment, calling the proposal an “assault on the remaining pieces of the state that kind of feel like old Florida.”
As public outcry continues to grow, the future of the Great Outdoors Initiative remains uncertain. The DEP’s plans for state park modernization are assured to face significant scrutiny as stakeholders and the public weigh in on the balance between recreation and conservation.
News in Brief: Florida’s Great Outdoors Initiative Sparks Controversy
As the debate surrounding the Great Outdoors Initiative intensifies, the future of Florida’s state parks hangs in the balance. While the proposal aims to modernize and expand recreational facilities, critics argue that the potential environmental costs outweigh the benefits. With significant opposition from environmental groups, residents, and some lawmakers, the DEP faces mounting pressure to reconsider its plans.
The upcoming public meetings and the growing petition against the initiative show the urgency of addressing these concerns. As stakeholders continue to voice their opinions, the outcome of this initiative will likely shape the future of Florida’s natural landscapes and its commitment to preserving them for future generations.
ALSO READ: Florida’s Pickleball Parks Expansion Faces Delay: Feedback Portal Live
