During spring training in Port St. Lucie, Florida, former New York Mets star Darryl Strawberry expressed sharp criticism over Pete Alonso’s recent decision to depart from the Mets, warning that it could haunt Alonso after his playing career ends. Strawberry believes Alonso missed a rare opportunity to cement his legacy by staying with the Mets, citing the potential for historic records and long-term recognition the first baseman forsook by opting to join the Baltimore Orioles.
Strawberry Reflects on the Lost Potential Alonso Had in New York
Strawberry noted that Alonso had the chance to rewrite the Mets’ record books but instead chose to leave, a decision that surprised many given the organization’s passionate fan base and unique market.
“Pete could have broken all the records,”
Strawberry said, after observing Mets batting practice, stressing that Alonso might one day regret stepping away from New York City’s spotlight and legacy.
He further commented on the difference in ownership between the Mets and Orioles, emphasizing the Mets’ connection with its players.
“You’ve got an owner that really cares. You’ve got an owner that will work with you if you work with him,”
Strawberry remarked, contrasting it against Alonso’s move.
Strawberry’s Personal Health Struggles Influence His Perspective
The 63-year-old Hall of Famer also opened up about his recent health challenges, revealing he suffered a heart attack two years ago and nearly died following complications from cosmetic dental surgery last winter. His survival, credited to his wife Tracy‘s quick actions, has deepened Strawberry’s reflection on career choices and legacy.
“I could have been gone if it was my time,”
he said, adding that he feels a strong sense of purpose moving forward, dedicating himself to helping others beyond baseball.
Frustration with Mets Front Office’s Role in Alonso’s Exit
Strawberry did not only place responsibility on Alonso but also criticized Mets baseball operations president David Stearns for allegedly not presenting an extension offer, which might have persuaded Alonso to remain. He suggested that a failure to negotiate more aggressively contributed to the split, arguing both parties could have done more to keep the star within the organization.
Despite Alonso securing a lucrative five-year, $155 million contract with Baltimore, Strawberry feels the financial aspect won’t replace what Alonso lost by departing the Mets in terms of historical acclaim and team allegiance.
Legacy and Records Alonso Left Unfinished with the Mets
Alonso broke Strawberry’s previous Mets home run record by hitting 264 homers, surpassing Strawberry’s 252, and is close to overtaking other franchise legends in runs batted in (RBIs). With 712 RBIs, Alonso trails Strawberry’s total by just 21 and remains far behind David Wright’s franchise-leading 970 RBIs, marking a trajectory toward historic status that was abruptly halted by his departure.
Strawberry argued that leaving New York likely means Alonso’s jersey number won’t be retired by the team due to the lack of a championship, which is often a key factor in such honors.
“He left before the miracle happened,”
Strawberry said referring to the Mets’ recent successes he hopes Alonso would have been part of, while acknowledging he does not know if Alonso felt slighted by the organization.
Tension and Negotiation Breakdown Surrounding Alonso’s Contract Decisions
After rejecting a seven-year, $158 million extension in 2023 as he eyed free agency following the 2024 season, Alonso experienced a down year and a less favorable market. These circumstances led him to re-sign with the Mets on a two-year deal featuring an opt-out clause, which he ultimately exercised. This period was marked by visible strain between Alonso and Mets management, with Alonso openly expressing disappointment about how the Mets valued him.
Alonso’s Own Remarks on His Departure and Current Outlook
Despite the controversy, Alonso recently told Newsday he feels appreciated by his current team and finds no need to dwell on hypothetical what-ifs.
“To where it’s like I feel so comfortable, so awesome with this group, that I don’t need to look back,”
he stated, signaling contentment with his new environment.
Strawberry Highlights the Unique Challenge of Winning in New York
While acknowledging Alonso’s confidence in Baltimore, Strawberry underscored the uniqueness of succeeding in New York’s demanding atmosphere.
“There’s no greater place to win than New York,”
he said, explaining the intense but loyal nature of Mets fans who require grit and toughness from their players.
He noted the distinction between being pushed out and choosing to leave, pointing out that he himself was forced out due to performance and attitude—but Alonso left on his own terms.
Strawberry’s Respect for Mets’ Rebuilding Efforts Despite Player Departures
Even while lamenting the loss of key players like Alonso, Brandon Nimmo, and Edwin Diaz, Strawberry praised David Stearns for his work reconstructing the Mets roster. He acknowledged the challenges of adapting new players and positions but remains optimistic about the team’s prospects.
“He knows baseball,” Strawberry said about Stearns, highlighting the acquisition of contact hitters capable of putting the ball in play consistently. Strawberry singled out recent additions Bo Bichette and Marcus Semien—the latter fresh from a World Series win with the Texas Rangers—as examples of leadership qualities the team now possesses.
Veteran Leadership and the Mets’ Future Challenges
Strawberry emphasized that leadership comes from everyday players who understand the game, implying that while the Mets had some of this in previous years, breakdowns ultimately prevented division titles. He cited the competition with rivals such as the Atlanta Braves and Philadelphia Phillies as ongoing hurdles for the franchise.
