The Milwaukee Brewers are already shaping their roster for the 2026 MLB season with two standout players projected to represent the team in the National League All-Star roster. As expectations rise for the Milwaukee Brewers 2026 All-Stars, catcher William Contreras and pitcher Jacob Misiorowski are forecasted to earn nods based on expert predictions and their demonstrated potential.
Brewers’ Top Prospects for the 2026 NL All-Star Roster
During his early 2026 preseason analysis, ESPN’s David Schoenfield highlighted just two Milwaukee Brewers as likely National League All-Stars, reflecting both the team’s rising talent and challenges. This prediction follows a previous year when three Brewers pitchers garnered All-Star recognition, although only Freddy Peralta was originally named, with trouble arising from his rest schedule and alternate selections by Trevor Megill and rookie Jacob Misiorowski.
William Contreras Expected to Lead as Starting Catcher
William Contreras, having earned two Silver Slugger awards and a 2024 All-Star starter selection, is anticipated to reclaim his status as a leading catcher for the Brewers. After a difficult 2025 season hampered by a broken finger that impacted his offensive performance, he is seen as primed for a comeback in 2026. Schoenfield regarded Contreras highly despite the position’s competitive depth:
“This is a deeper position than you might realize. Contreras, after finishing fifth in the 2024 NL MVP voting, played through a fractured middle finger all of last season and saw his offensive numbers dip a bit.
Will Smithis a three-time All-Star.Hunter Goodmanhit 31 home runs for the Rockies.Drake Baldwinis an up-and-coming bat-first catcher who had an outstanding rookie season and then you have defensive specialists likePatrick BaileyandGabriel Moreno.
We’ll go with Contreras, who should see a rebound in his power numbers, has turned into a solid defensive catcher, and might play 150 games again, starting at DH when he doesn’t catch.”
– David Schoenfield, ESPN Analyst
During his initial seasons in Milwaukee, Contreras achieved a .285 batting average combined with a robust slugging percentage, averaging 20 home runs and 85 runs batted in per season. His 2025 campaign suffered due to injury, concluding with a .260 average, 17 homers, and 76 RBIs. Returning to full health could enable Contreras to bounce back as a vital offensive and defensive presence behind the plate.
Jacob Misiorowski Positioned as a Key Pitching Reserve
Jacob Misiorowski, whose emergence in 2025 stirred both praise and skepticism, is projected to solidify his role as a key pitcher for the Brewers. His previous All-Star selection was contentious, given he made only five Major League starts at the time, with control and durability cited as critical areas for improvement. Schoenfield expressed confidence that Misiorowski could earn a deserved All-Star nomination in 2026:
“Misiorowski was a controversial All-Star last year, a late addition to the squad after making just five career starts. If he can improve his control, he’ll earn that selection this year.”
– David Schoenfield, ESPN Analyst
Misiorowski’s endurance over a full Major League season remains an open question. In 2025, he pitched 129.1 innings across minor and major league levels, surpassing his prior workload by 32 innings. Effective management of his workload and continued improvement in command will be vital for his success and ability to contribute consistently throughout the season.
Recent Milwaukee Brewers Updates from Wisconsin Sports Media
Besides the predicted All-Star representation, the Brewers remain active in offseason developments. Among notable recent news, the Mets made significant announcements involving Freddy Peralta for the 2026 season, the former Brewers ace detailed his decision to sit out the 2026 World Baseball Classic, and there are calls within the Brewers organization to acquire a third baseman with a strong home run track record over the past two years.
Outlook for the Milwaukee Brewers and Their Emerging Stars
The anticipation surrounding William Contreras and Jacob Misiorowski highlights the Brewers’ strategy to blend returning talent with developing players as they aim to contend in the National League. Contreras’s projected rebound from injury and Misiorowski’s task to prove his reliability will be crucial metrics tracked by fans and analysts alike. Their performances in 2026 will not only affect the Brewers’ fortunes but also shape the broader National League All-Star landscape.
