Derek Carr’s retirement from the NFL last year may only be a temporary pause in his football journey, as several teams could offer him a starting role should he decide to return. This potential comeback draws attention due to the unique situations unfolding across the league, where Carr’s experience might fill critical quarterback needs.
Teams That Might Lure Derek Carr Back Into the NFL
After spending 11 seasons in the NFL and earning four Pro Bowl appearances, Derek Carr stepped away from the game following rotator cuff surgery, seemingly closing the chapter on his career. However, a report from NFL Media’s Ian Rapoport, Mike Garafolo, and Tom Pelissero suggests Carr could come back if presented with the right opportunity. The Cincinnati Bengals even reached out to Carr after losing Joe Burrow to turf toe injuries, highlighting his potential value as a reliable option.
Opportunity for a Fresh Start in Arizona
The Arizona Cardinals, who endured a dismal 3-14 season that led to the firing of head coach Jonathan Gannon, are preparing to overhaul their roster, including moving on from quarterback Kyler Murray. Despite possessing the third overall draft pick, the Cardinals are unlikely to select a quarterback this year due to a lack of standout prospects in this draft class.
This situation makes pairing Carr with new head coach Mike LaFleur a compelling prospect. Carr would benefit from reuniting with a Shanahan-style offensive system, reminiscent of his early success under Klint Kubiak before injury sidelined him in 2024. Moreover, the Cardinals boast emerging playmakers like Marvin Harrison Jr., Trey McBride, and Michael Wilson, who could provide Carr with immediate weapons in the passing game.
Potential Fit with the Miami Dolphins
Similar to Arizona, the Miami Dolphins appear ready to move on from a struggling high draft pick, with plans to trade or release quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. This scenario opens another door for Carr to re-enter the NFL and join an offense led by new coordinator Bobby Slowik, a Shanahan disciple as well.
Although Miami faces ongoing offensive line challenges and Slowik’s coaching tenure with the Houston Texans ended on a low note, Carr could be attracted by the chance to work with talented receivers like Jaylen Waddle and De’Von Achane. Additionally, reconnecting with tight end Darren Waller—who is entering free agency—adds to the appeal of a Dolphins comeback.
A Chance to Compete in Minnesota
The Minnesota Vikings invested heavily in quarterback J.J. McCarthy last offseason, a choice that looks questionable as McCarthy struggled during the 9-8 campaign. In contrast, Sam Darnold, whom the Vikings bypassed, recently guided the Seattle Seahawks to a Super Bowl victory, drawing attention to Minnesota’s decision.
With McCarthy’s inconsistency, the Vikings are likely seeking competition at quarterback. Carr could step in as a frontrunner for the starting spot, especially considering his readiness and ability to work with head coach Kevin O’Connell. The prospect of throwing to star receiver Justin Jefferson also makes this an attractive chance for Carr to impact a team eager to reestablish itself as a playoff contender.
Despite sitting out a year, Carr’s experience and skill set could position him as the leading candidate in a quarterback battle, bringing hope to a Vikings franchise looking to return to postseason relevance.
What Derek Carr’s Return Could Mean for the NFL
Should Derek Carr choose to return, his presence would affect not only the teams mentioned but potentially the balance of power among contenders. His familiarity with innovative offensive systems and proven ability to perform under pressure make him a valuable asset for quarterbacks-needy teams. Each potential landing spot offers different challenges and opportunities, from Arizona’s rebuilding project to Miami’s offensive promise and Minnesota’s need for stability.
Carr’s comeback would also underscore the fluid nature of NFL careers, where injuries and circumstances continually reshape team rosters. For Carr himself, returning to play could be a chance at redemption and another shot at extending an already notable NFL legacy.
