This offseason, much speculation surrounds the possibility that the San Francisco 49ers might trade quarterback Mac Jones. While recent rumors indicate the team intends to retain him, the 49ers could reconsider if a strong offer emerged that would strengthen another part of the roster. Still, some proposed deals seem unlikely to gain traction with the franchise.
Unusual Trade Idea Involving Minnesota Vikings’ J.J. McCarthy
One surprising mock trade suggested by ESPN’s Bill Barnwell involves sending Jones to the Minnesota Vikings in exchange for quarterback J.J. McCarthy. However, the benefits of this swap for San Francisco remain unclear, raising doubts about its appeal to the 49ers’ front office.
McCarthy, an early-career NFL player drafted out of the University of Michigan, showed initial promise during the 2024 preseason. Unfortunately, a knee injury cut short his rookie season, which allowed Sam Darnold to step up and eventually move on to the Seattle Seahawks, where he earned a Super Bowl win.
Performance and Potential of J.J. McCarthy
Returning from injury, McCarthy became Minnesota’s starting quarterback in 2025, but his season was inconsistent. Across 10 starts, he completed 57.6% of his passes for 1,632 yards, throwing 11 touchdowns against 12 interceptions, and ran for 181 yards with four rushing touchdowns. Though he possesses upside, his injury history and mixed results may make him a risky acquisition for the 49ers.
Why Trading Mac Jones for McCarthy Is Improbable
The 49ers currently have proven backup options and likely do not see value in exchanging a reliable quarterback like Jones for another player still establishing himself. They would prefer to receive draft picks or contribute to acquiring a high-impact player rather than trading Jones for an unsettled talent. For example, acquiring a pick to strengthen their defense or wide receiver corps, or packaging Jones in a deal for a star defender such as Raiders edge rusher Maxx Crosby, would better align with their goals.
Minnesota as a Possible Destination for Mac Jones
Although the specific trade for McCarthy might not be favorable, Minnesota remains a plausible landing spot for Jones. The Vikings enjoyed success with Sam Darnold after his stint with the 49ers before letting him join Seattle, a move they may now regret. Bringing in Jones could be a way to address the void left when Darnold departed.
San Francisco’s Need for Strategic Moves Regarding Jones
Any decision by the 49ers to move Mac Jones must be carefully considered, given his demonstrated importance last season when filling in for Brock Purdy. The team should avoid trading him without significant return, as his value goes beyond just a backup quarterback. Rather than a hasty trade, the 49ers will likely wait for opportunities that offer clear roster upgrades or draft capital.
Mock trade by ESPN’s Bill Barnwell:
49ers receive:
J.J. McCarthyVikings receive:
Mac Jones pic.twitter.com/tW8CyHgLm3— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) February 15, 2026
