The Pittsburgh Steelers must decide the future of tight end/fullback Connor Heyward, an unrestricted free agent entering the 2025 season with a $1,138,806 salary cap hit. Heyward, a member of the 2022 draft class, delivered his most productive season last year, demonstrating his versatility on offense and special teams despite limited offensive snaps. His continued presence could be pivotal amid a coaching staff overhaul and evolving team strategy.
Performance Highlights from the 2024 Season
Heyward’s offensive involvement last season was limited to just 90 snaps, a notable decrease from previous years, yet his contribution remained significant, particularly with the “Spartan sneak” variant of the “Tush Push” play that he led effectively. Across the season, Heyward recorded 15 rushing attempts for 43 yards, securing 11 first downs and scoring one rushing touchdown. He also caught three passes for an additional touchdown on just four targets. These statistics reflect a player who, while not heavily featured, maximized his opportunities in critical moments.
More importantly, Heyward logged 290 special teams snaps and registered nine tackles, underscoring his valuable role beyond offense. With safety Miles Killebrew likely to depart in free agency, Heyward’s importance as a special teams contributor may increase, making him a key asset in that phase of the game.
Changing Coaching Dynamics Influence Heyward’s Future
The Steelers have undergone substantial coaching changes with Mike Tomlin’s resignation and the departures of offensive coordinator Arthur Smith and tight ends coach Alfredo Roberts, both known for their tight end expertise. The new regime under head coach Mike McCarthy brings uncertainty regarding Heyward’s place in the offense or special teams. Interestingly, McCarthy’s Dallas Cowboys were reportedly opposed to the “Tush Push” play, which Heyward helped run effectively in Pittsburgh. This contrast adds a layer of unpredictability to his future utilization.
Free Agency Outlook and Strategic Considerations
Connor Heyward’s versatility and standout special teams play suggest he should be a priority re-signing target for the Steelers, potentially on an affordable deal reflecting his primary value as a top-tier special teamer. If the Steelers release tight end Jonnu Smith, Heyward could see an expanded offensive role, especially given his improvements as a blocker this past season. However, it is crucial to acknowledge that quality special teamers command meaningful contracts, and a multi-year deal in the range of $12 to $15 million would not be unreasonable.
The wider Steelers roster features several free agents, including notable players like Kenneth Gainwell and Isaac Seumalo, but none appear as critical to retain as quarterback Aaron Rodgers, who the organization has publicly expressed the desire to re-sign. The quarterback position remains the highest priority, with no anticipated repeat of previous quarterback uncertainties like the Mason Rudolph era.
Implications of a New Era for Pittsburgh
Entering a phase under fresh leadership, the Steelers’ strategy in free agency and roster building remains fluid. Decisions made between February and March could include unexpected releases, bold trades, or targeted acquisitions as the team adapts to new schemes and philosophies. Connor Heyward’s future contract and role will likely reflect these broader shifts, representing both a practical and symbolic sign of the Steelers’ direction.
