During the 2025 NFL season, despite the Pittsburgh Steelers defense showing inconsistency overall, edge defenders Alex Highsmith and Nick Herbig delivered notable performances that earned them recognition. Pro Football Focus (PFF) ranked Herbig sixth and Highsmith eleventh among edge defenders, highlighting their impact on the field. Herbig, selected in the fourth round, improved his run defense significantly and recorded 7.5 sacks alongside 18 quarterback hits in limited action. Highsmith produced a career-best run-defense grade of 82.2 while accumulating 9.5 sacks and 15 tackles for loss.
Key Statistics Reflecting Defensive Impact
The two defenders stood out with strong individual metrics: Nick Herbig achieved an 87.3 pass-rush grade with a 73.0 run-defense grade, while Alex Highsmith posted an impressive 82.2 run-defense grade that complemented his sack total. These numbers indicate their vital roles within a defensive unit that struggled to live up to preseason expectations. Their efforts proved crucial amid a crowded group of edge rushers vying for playing time.
Challenges and Future Considerations for Pittsburgh’s Defense
Even though Herbig and Highsmith excelled, the overall defense faced challenges in consistency throughout the season. The presence of multiple talented edge rushers generates difficult decisions about how to allocate snaps and manage the roster moving forward. With the Steelers preparing for 2026, questions remain about potential trades and adjustments that could affect their edge-rushing strategy.
Outlook for Steelers’ Edge Rushers Moving Forward
The strong showing from both Highsmith and Herbig in 2025 points to a promising future if the team balances their defensive lineup thoughtfully. Herbig’s performance suggests he deserves increased playing time, and strategic management of the edge rusher rotation will be key to maximizing the unit’s effectiveness. These developments highlight the importance of making careful roster moves to build on the foundation established by these emerging defensive talents.
“Herbig, a fourth-round pick, notably improved his run-defense grade and demonstrated effectiveness with 7.5 sacks and 18 quarterback hits in limited playing time.” – Pro Football Focus
“Highsmith also excelled, contributing 9.5 sacks and an 82.2 run-defense grade, marking his career-best.” – Pro Football Focus
“Herbig and Highsmith highlighted their capabilities in 2025, signaling a bright future for the Steelers if managed effectively.” – Steelers Depot
