A former NFL general manager recently suggested that the Cleveland Browns should consider initiating a substantial trade involving star defensive end Myles Garrett. This recommendation comes after a turbulent season for the Browns, who struggled to resolve their quarterback issues despite some individual standouts, including Garrett, who set the record for most sacks in a single season.
As the Browns approach the 2026 NFL Draft under new leadership, questions remain about their future, particularly at quarterback. However, the retired executive turned media analyst argues that trading Garrett could accelerate the team’s rebuilding process.
Challenges Persist Despite Defensive Strengths
The Browns’ roster shows few weak spots aside from a vulnerable offensive line and uncertainties at quarterback. Deshaun Watson’s presence has complicated the situation, while recent candidates from the 2025 season such as Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders failed to secure a definitive starting role. Consequently, the team will confront difficult decisions at the upcoming draft.
Mike Tannenbaum, former general manager of the New York Jets and current ESPN analyst, advocates for the Browns to move on from Garrett. He suggests that the Browns could acquire significant assets by trading their premier defender.
“Two first-round picks and Jameson Williams to the Detroit Lions, who says no?”
— Mike Tannenbaum, Former Jets GM and ESPN Analyst
Tannenbaum emphasized the value of the potential trade package, noting that the Browns’ extensive rebuilding needs make such an offer highly attractive.
“If you’re the Browns, you have such a big rebuild. Two first-round picks and you get a young, explosive player. 17 touchdowns in his career, 17 yards per catch. You need so many weapons, you have so many holes to fill. If I’m the Browns, I do that to start the massive rebuild.”
— Mike Tannenbaum, Former Jets GM and ESPN Analyst
Trade Value and Team Outlook
Myles Garrett, a two-time Defensive Player of the Year, remains one of the NFL’s most dominant defenders. His impact was highlighted in 2025 when he led PFSN’s NFL EDGE Impact Rankings with a 95.6 score. Despite this, the Browns may find the short-term loss of Garrett outweighed by the long-term benefits of the trade haul, particularly with persistent issues across their roster.
Tannenbaum brings credibility to the debate having led the Jets to three playoff appearances during his tenure from 2006, when he replaced Terry Bradway as general manager. His perspective underscores the complexity of the Browns’ dilemma, balancing immediate on-field talent against broader strategic rebuilding goals.
What the Browns’ Next Steps Could Mean
Trading Myles Garrett would mark a pivotal shift for the Browns, signaling a commitment to restructuring rather than relying on star power alone. The assets acquired through such a trade could provide the team with much-needed depth and young talent, potentially reshaping their trajectory in the coming seasons.
As Cleveland faces unresolved quarterback issues and an offensive line needing improvement, the decision to trade Garrett represents a gamble on future growth over present stability. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see how the Browns approach both the draft and potential trades in the months ahead.
Should the Browns be listening to trade offers for Myles Garrett? 🤔
—@RealTannenbaum reveals an offer the Browns shouldn’t refuse… pic.twitter.com/U8epBMdLdR
— Get Up (@GetUpESPN) February 27, 2026
