The Pittsburgh Steelers face uncertainty at quarterback heading into the 2026 season, with veteran Aaron Rodgers’ status still unresolved. Despite Rodgers leading the team through the 2025 season, the Steelers are cautiously exploring options to prepare for potential changes at the position.
Currently, the team is navigating the possibility that Rodgers might retire or step away, prompting them to assess quarterback prospects who could eventually take the reins. Their approach at the 2026 NFL Combine suggests the Steelers are carefully evaluating young passers to ensure they are ready for any outcome.
Three Rookie Quarterbacks Attract Steelers’ Attention at the Combine
In 2025, Aaron Rodgers guided Pittsburgh to an AFC North division title, completing a solid season with 3,322 passing yards, 24 touchdowns, and seven interceptions. Although Rodgers’ performance reflected a decline from his prime, he remains a viable starter for the immediate future if he decides to continue playing.
Mike DeFabo of The Athletic reported that the Steelers held formal meetings with three quarterback prospects during the NFL Combine: Alabama’s Ty Simpson, Penn State’s Drew Allar, and Miami’s Carson Beck.
The Steelers met formally with three quarterbacks this week: Alabama’s Ty Simpson, a potential first-round pick, Penn State’s Drew Allar and Miami’s Carson Beck,
DeFabo explained.
I heard from several people that all three had positive meetings. At least above the neck, they put their best foot forward.
Ty Simpson stands out as a likely first-round selection after passing for 3,567 yards and 28 touchdowns, while managing only five interceptions. He was instrumental in leading Alabama to the College Football Playoff. Carson Beck impressed in his initial season at Miami, registering 3,813 yards and 30 touchdowns, and helping propel the Hurricanes to the national championship game.
Drew Allar, once viewed as a top quarterback prospect, experienced setback in 2025 due to a season-ending injury after playing just six games. Though his draft stock might have been affected, the Steelers’ interest suggests they consider his potential value moving forward.
The Steelers’ Strategic Outlook on Quarterback Selection
By meeting with three promising passers, the Steelers have made it clear that drafting a quarterback remains a strong possibility in 2026. They previously added Ohio State quarterback Will Howard in the sixth round of the 2025 NFL Draft, showing a willingness to develop young talent behind Rodgers if needed.
The recent coaching change from Mike Tomlin to Mike McCarthy adds complexity to Pittsburgh’s quarterback situation. McCarthy previously collaborated with Rodgers during their Super Bowl run in Green Bay, although it remains uncertain whether that partnership will continue in Pittsburgh.
McCarthy might seek to rebuild the team around a new quarterback, possibly opting for a fresh start in 2026. Alternatively, he could aim to extend Rodgers’ tenure through another season before transitioning to a younger signal-caller in 2027. Either approach highlights how pivotal the quarterback decision is for the franchise’s immediate and future success.
Implications for the Steelers and AFC North Rivalry
Pittsburgh’s quarterback strategy will significantly influence its ability to defend its AFC North title. While the roster has multiple other areas needing enhancement, solidifying the quarterback role is essential to maintaining competitiveness.
Holding the 21st pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, the Steelers are positioned to pursue a promising rookie if Rodgers retires or if McCarthy desires a long-term solution under center. Their cautious approach toward quarterback prospects reflects the high stakes of this decision, balancing respect for Rodgers’ veteran experience with prudent preparation for transition.
