Joshua Roy, a 22-year-old winger from Saint-Georges-de-Beauce and a 2021 fifth-round draft pick, remains a debated prospect within the Montreal Canadiens. Standing 6-foot tall and weighing 192 pounds, Roy is a left-handed shooter known for notable offensive skills. While he has displayed flashes of promise in the NHL, his overall production in 38 games—6 goals and 5 assists—has not yet distinguished him as a guaranteed NHL regular. His future with the Canadiens has become a topic of speculation, particularly given the depth ahead of him on Montreal’s forward lines.
Performance Differences Between NHL and AHL Appearances
This season, Roy has split his time between the NHL’s Canadiens and their AHL affiliate, the Laval Rocket. In limited opportunity with Montreal—just three NHL games—he has yet to register a point, receiving mostly depth minutes or sitting as a healthy scratch. However, Roy’s performance in Laval has been much stronger, where in 37 games he has compiled 13 goals and 15 assists. His steady top-six-level output in the AHL suggests he is progressing, leading some to say,
“Okay, he’s ready for another look.”
Despite these promising signs, Montreal’s forward roster is crowded with young talents and established veterans holding steady roles, making consistent NHL ice time hard to come by for Roy. His NHL outings have often been uneven, occasionally showing bright moments, but sometimes faltering in pace or defense, which has resulted in him being sent back to the press box.
Potential for a Trade Before the Deadline
Roy’s contract situation makes him an attractive trade candidate. With a cap hit of $835,000 and restricted free agent status approaching next summer, he is relatively easy to move. As the NHL trade deadline nears in March, there is a plausible argument that Montreal could package Roy in a deal to acquire a veteran winger or additional playoff support. His youth, prior success in the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League where he posted 99 points in one season, and experience as a World Juniors gold medalist all add value.
On the other hand, trading Roy carries the risk of seeing him flourish elsewhere, which could lead to regret among Canadiens fans about losing a potentially impactful player prematurely.
Arguments for Continuing Development within Montreal’s System
Some advocate for patience, preferring to let Roy continue honing his skills in Laval while earning occasional NHL call-ups. Fans recall instances when the Habs traded prospects too soon to their detriment, suggesting that a cautious approach could be wise. Roy currently stands at a development crossroads: too skilled for a full-time AHL role, yet not firmly established in the NHL. His remaining upside means there is still room for growth if given time and opportunity.
Decisions Facing the Canadiens on Roy’s Future
The Canadiens face a difficult decision regarding Joshua Roy’s trajectory. Moving him could clear roster space and deliver immediate help but carries the risk of losing a player who might break out elsewhere. Keeping him means potentially blocking others while investing in Roy’s longer-term development. As Roy has the necessary tools to succeed, the question hinges on whether Montreal is prepared to give him extended time to mature or prefers to use him as leverage in trades.
At this critical juncture, the Canadiens must soon determine which path best aligns with their competitive and organizational goals.
