The Minnesota Vikings are exploring options to secure their quarterback position as they prepare for the 2026 season, primarily due to ongoing concerns regarding J.J. McCarthy’s durability and performance. After missing his entire rookie year in 2024 with a meniscus injury and playing only 10 games in 2025 due to multiple physical setbacks, questions remain about McCarthy’s ability to lead the team consistently. The Vikings are considering veteran alternatives to provide insurance at the quarterback spot while maintaining competitiveness.
J.J. McCarthy’s Struggles and the Team’s Previous Decisions
J.J. McCarthy, the Vikings’ 10th overall pick in the 2024 draft, completed his second year with mixed results on the field, throwing for 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions, alongside a 57.6% completion rate and enduring 27 sacks. His inconsistent performance, combined with his health issues, has made the Vikings cautious about relying solely on him.
Complicating matters, the team’s 2024 starting quarterback, Sam Darnold, now plays in the Super Bowl for the Seattle Seahawks. Darnold’s impressive performance in McCarthy’s absence—completing over 4,000 yards and securing 14 wins—contrasts sharply with Minnesota’s decision to let him leave and trust McCarthy as the starter in 2025. This choice contributed to the dismissal of former Vikings general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah.
Reconsidering Kirk Cousins as a Veteran Quarterback Option
The Vikings are reportedly considering bringing back Kirk Cousins, their former longtime starting quarterback, as veteran reinforcement. Cousins, who signed a lucrative free agent deal with the Atlanta Falcons, has recently lost his starting job to rookie Michael Penix Jr., the No. 8 overall pick in the same draft that saw McCarthy selected.
Dianna Russini of The Athletic highlighted the possibility of Cousins returning to Minnesota, noting his eagerness to resume a full-time starting role and the Falcons’ need for a reliable backup given Penix’s recovery from a third ACL surgery. Russini also pointed out that Atlanta’s new head coach, Kevin Stefanski, served as Cousins’ offensive coordinator in Minnesota, potentially easing a reunion with the Vikings.
“Cousins has made no secret of his desire to become a full-time starter again,”
Russini wrote.
“But Atlanta needs a capable backup, especially one who might have to play early as Michael Penix Jr. works his way back from his third ACL surgery. There’s also the Kevin Stefanski factor. Atlanta’s new head coach served as Cousins’ OC for one season in Minnesota.”
– Dianna Russini, The Athletic
“I’m watching to see if the Falcons find any parties interested in their backup,”
she continued.
“Speaking of those Vikings, one league source speculated that Cousins could be an option there, given his history with Kevin O’Connell and Minnesota’s desire to bring in competition for young J.J. McCarthy.”
– Dianna Russini, The Athletic
Fans and Management Debate Targeting Bengals QB Joe Burrow
While the Vikings’ management weighs veteran options like Kirk Cousins, fans are calling for an even bolder approach by targeting Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow. However, sources indicate the Bengals have no plans to trade Burrow, who remains a central figure in their offense.
“Despite the hopes and dreams of Minnesota Vikings fans, the Cincinnati Bengals have no intention of trading Joe Burrow — to Minnesota or anywhere else,”
Russini shared.
“As for Burrow’s overall happiness? Bengals star wide receiver Ja’Marr Chase told me he isn’t worried about Burrow’s future, despite late-season speculation after another missed playoff opportunity.”
– Dianna Russini, The Athletic
Implications for the Vikings’ Quarterback Future
With J.J. McCarthy’s future clouded by injuries and inconsistent play, the Vikings face critical decisions to address the quarterback position’s stability. The potential return of Kirk Cousins could offer a familiar and experienced option, providing competition and depth behind McCarthy. Meanwhile, the pursuit of Joe Burrow appears unlikely, given the Bengals’ firm stance on keeping their franchise quarterback.
As Minnesota moves closer to 2026, the team’s approach to securing leadership at quarterback will be pivotal in determining its competitiveness. Whether the Vikings choose to reintegrate Cousins, continue developing McCarthy, or explore other alternatives, the quarterback role remains a focal point for the organization’s future success.
