The Pittsburgh Steelers are considering a significant shift at quarterback as they weigh the possibility of trading for Derek Carr, potentially moving on from Aaron Rodgers. While Rodgers has continued to play at an advanced age of 42, Carr, at 34, represents a younger alternative who might rejuvenate the position after sitting out the 2025 season due to injury concerns. Given the Steelers’ need for a reliable presence under center, Carr’s availability for trade presents a possible solution to their quarterback dilemma.
Though Carr has no prior connection to new head coach Mike McCarthy, the Steelers’ leadership faces limited choices, namely Rodgers or Kirk Cousins. McCarthy and Rodgers share a complex history but maintain mutual respect, while Cousins appears more likely to return to the Minnesota Vikings than take a risk in Pittsburgh. Carr, having had a full year to recover from injury and with no current playing commitments, differs as an intriguing candidate.
What Would It Take for the Steelers to Acquire Derek Carr?
The most straightforward path for the Steelers might be to re-sign Rodgers, but uncertainty surrounds his commitment for the 2026 season, especially after Mike Tomlin’s departure. Rodgers is reportedly keeping his options open, including potential interest from the Vikings where he could reunite with coach Kevin O’Connell. Pittsburgh must therefore consider alternative plans to avoid instability at quarterback.
Derek Carr did not play in 2025 and reportedly has no plans to return to the New Orleans Saints, who appear to have moved forward with Tyler Shough as their future signal-caller. However, the Saints retain Carr’s rights, meaning Pittsburgh could negotiate a trade to bring him onboard. This move could provide competition for younger quarterbacks like Will Howard or future draft picks in 2026, giving the Steelers a veteran presence to bridge transition years.
A third-round draft pick seems a reasonable price for a quarterback of Carr’s ability, especially considering his recent rest and recovery. Derek Carr and his brother, David Carr, have even joked about a possible comeback, noting improved health following his torn labrum and time off.
Never say never. Because I’ve learned that when I say never, it usually happens,
Derek Carr said a few months ago.
Anticipated Role and Expectations if Carr Joins the Steelers
Pittsburgh’s expectations for Carr should remain measured, as the team is undergoing a period of transition and may need to rely on short-term solutions at quarterback. With Kenny Pickett having struggled, and Will Howard unproven, the Steelers are still searching for a stable leader at the position. The upcoming draft class is not expected to immediately solve their challenges, making Carr a plausible stopgap option to maintain competitiveness.
Acquiring Carr would allow Pittsburgh to maintain patience while seeking improvements elsewhere, such as reinforcing their offensive line and adding wide receiver talent after a difficult past season for that unit—outside of standout DK Metcalf. Carr would benefit from an improving supporting cast, potentially enabling him to contribute effectively if he chooses to return.
If Carr is genuinely interested in a comeback—and current signals indicate he might be—the Steelers could engage with him early in the offseason to explore a short-term commitment. The franchise is committed to winning, and owner Art Rooney Jr. has emphasized that the exit of Mike Tomlin does not mean that losing seasons should become the norm.
