Mason Rudolph currently finds himself in a precarious position within the Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback lineup, with many fans and analysts seemingly moving on from him. Despite once being a favored prospect, Rudolph’s presence is overshadowed by the rising attention toward rookie Will Howard and ongoing speculation about Aaron Rodgers’ return. The uncertainty surrounding Rodgers’ future with the team has significant implications for Rudolph’s role and security in Pittsburgh.
Analysis Suggests Rudolph May Be Pushed Aside Regardless of Rodgers’ Decision
Sports journalist Ray Fittipaldo has expressed concerns that Rudolph’s place on the Steelers roster is far from guaranteed. Rudolph has previously left the team but returned, perhaps optimistic about eventually earning a starting opportunity. While some still envision him potentially starting if Rodgers opts out in the coming years, this outlook is far from universal inside the organization.
If Rodgers comes back, I think the Steelers will groom Howard to be the backup this year
, Fittipaldo remarked during a recent Pittsburgh Post-Gazette chat session.
That would leave Rudolph’s place on the roster a bit uncertain. Could he be No. 3? Sure. He’s not making a ton of money. But they could also cut Rudolph and take a flyer on a QB in the draft who could be the No. 3
.
New Coach McCarthy Favors Rookies While Respecting Rudolph
Mike McCarthy, who recently took over as the Steelers’ head coach, has consistently spoken highly of Will Howard, further fueling expectations about the rookie’s future role. While McCarthy has not offered much public commentary on Rudolph, it is clear the quarterback still commands respect within the team’s locker room. Nevertheless, internal respect does not guarantee a roster spot, especially with two other respected quarterbacks already competing for positions.
Steelers Signal Commitment to Will Howard Regardless of Rodgers’ Status
Fittipaldo points out that the Steelers have made clear their enthusiasm for Howard, signaling that they plan to elevate him to the backup quarterback role soon. Importantly, this strategy appears to hold no matter whether Rodgers returns or not. Fittipaldo explained,
If Rodgers does not come back, I think Howard is still groomed to be the backup, but they’d have to acquire a starter in free agency or a trade
. This suggests that Rudolph would remain at best a third-string option or could be released entirely.
Background: Rudolph’s Journey and Performance History
Mason Rudolph was selected by the Steelers in the third round of the 2018 NFL Draft, chosen for his potential to eventually start despite the team’s quarterback depth at the time. The Steelers already had Landry Jones and Joshua Dobbs on the roster when Rudolph was drafted. By 2019, Rudolph had secured the backup position, but his tenure did not meet expectations.
Following a short stint with the Tennessee Titans in 2024, where he compiled a 1-4 record over five starts, Rudolph rejoined the Steelers. Last season, he completed 38 of 52 passes for 310 yards, throwing two touchdowns alongside two interceptions, but lost his only start. His most notable contribution came late in the 2023 season when injuries and poor performance by other quarterbacks thrust him into the starting role. Rudolph helped the Steelers win three consecutive games to secure a playoff berth, though he managed just three touchdown passes in those contests and did not find success in the postseason.
Uncertain Outlook for Rudolph as Steelers Prepare for Future Moves
Mason Rudolph’s position within the Steelers’ quarterback room remains uncertain amid the team’s evolving strategy and roster decisions. Given the organization’s interest in developing Will Howard as a backup and likely acquiring a starter through free agency or trade if Rodgers does not return, Rudolph faces the possibility of being surpassed or waived. The coming months will be critical for Rudolph as the Steelers finalize their quarterback depth chart and plan for the 2025 season and beyond.
