MONTREAL — Returning to action after a three-week break, the New York Islanders and Montreal Canadiens struggled to find their rhythm on Thursday night, but ultimately the Islanders secured a 4-3 overtime victory thanks to Jean-Gabriel Pageau’s decisive goal 1:46 into extra time. The closely contested game reflected both teams’ attempts to shake off rust after the hiatus, with neither squad performing at their best but producing an exciting finish.
Early Game Struggles and Breakthroughs
The game began with a sluggish pace, reminiscent of players recovering from travel fatigue. Both teams appeared disjointed, missing passes and lacking speed at various moments. Nevertheless, defensemen Noah Dobson and rookie Matthew Schaefer emerged as key contributors. Dobson scored twice against his former team, while Schaefer matched those efforts for the Islanders, setting up an evenly poised contest heading into the final period.
Third Period Dynamics and Crucial Equalizer
The Canadiens broke the deadlock in the third when Cole Caufield capitalized on Ivan Demidov’s cross-crease assist during a power play at 9:11, giving Montreal a 3-2 lead. The Islanders intensified their attack in response, applying pressure throughout the remaining minutes. With just 1:41 left, Bo Horvat scored his 900th career goal by tipping in a shot from Anders Lee during a six-on-five advantage, leveling the score at three and forcing overtime.
Overtime Thriller and Pageau’s Game-Winning Score
Overtime started with limited puck possession for the Islanders, but Simon Holmstrom’s defensive zone faceoff win set the stage for Pageau. Breaking free, Pageau used a backhand shot to beat Canadiens goalie Samuel Montembeault and clinch the victory.
I have that feeling this year,
Pageau said.
When we get down, we always have a chance to come back.
Pageau’s goal underscored the Islanders’ resilience despite a game that was far from clean.
Schaefer’s Record-Breaking Night and Impact on Team
Schaefer’s contributions stood out, scoring two goals 55 seconds apart late in the second period, including a dazzling solo effort where he skated over 270 feet in a creative maneuver behind the net before firing a shot from the right circle. His first goal tied franchise and NHL rookie defenseman records, while the second set new marks surpassing legends Denis Potvin and Phil Housley. This remarkable performance reinforced Schaefer’s rising importance for the Islanders.
I thought we fought so hard. It’s so fun playing with this group of guys. I love coming to the rink when all the boys are going to war.
Schaefer said.
Head coach Patrick Roy praised Schaefer’s hockey intelligence, stating,
If there’s something I’ve seen pretty fast, it’s that.
Schaefer’s two goals came in response to a challenging second period that saw the Islanders trailing 2-0, illustrating the team’s determination to stay competitive.
Dobson’s Contributions Reflect Positive Adjustment to Canadiens
Noah Dobson’s two goals for Montreal demonstrated his growing chemistry with the Canadiens following his move from the Islanders. The first was a sharp left-circle wrist shot while the Islanders were caught in a line change, and the second was a power play slap shot from the top of the zone. His performance already surpasses last season’s scoring totals, signaling a promising outlook in Montreal.
Game Context and Broader Team Narratives
Both teams showed moments of uneven play, characteristic of post-break games as players regain form. The Islanders’ ability to overcome deficits and the outstanding performances from Schaefer and Pageau highlight their potential depth and resilience this season. Montreal’s effort, led by emerging talents like Caufield and Demidov, hints at continued growth despite the loss.
Bo Horvat’s milestone of 900 career games added a meaningful personal achievement within the team’s collective effort. The Islanders’ blend of veteran leadership and youthful energy sets up an intriguing trajectory moving forward.
Looking Ahead: Implications for Both Teams
The Islanders’ overtime triumph helps build momentum after the season’s break, showcasing the clutch scoring ability of Pageau and the emergence of Schaefer as a defensive cornerstone. Montreal, while showing flashes of offense and skill, may need to refine consistency and cohesion as they progress.
This game serves as a reminder of the fine margins in the NHL, where resilience and timely contributions from defensemen can sway results. The Islanders will likely lean on these strengths as they continue their campaign, while the Canadiens aim to capitalize on young talent and improve as the schedule unfolds.
