On Tuesday, Gotham FC announced that forward Katie Stengel has signed a contract extension to remain with the club through the National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL) season of 2025. The 33-year-old, now in her second tenure with Gotham FC, returns to help lead the team in their continued pursuit of championships.
Stengel’s Impact and Experience with Gotham FC
Katie Stengel rejoined Gotham FC in July after playing for Crystal Palace in England. Throughout her career with Gotham, she has become known for delivering critical goals, especially during postseason play, helping the team secure two NWSL titles. Her commitment to the club was clear when she said,
“This club has meant a lot to me, and I’m excited to continue this journey with Gotham,”
adding,
“We’ve set a high standard here, and I’m motivated every day to help the team compete for championships.”
Yael Averbuch West, Gotham FC’s general manager and head of soccer operations, praised Stengel, stating,
“Katie has been a key contributor in our club’s success and brings a wealth of experience to our group. She’s a proven competitor who understands what it takes to win in this league, and we’re excited to have her continue with us.”
During her time with Gotham, Stengel has appeared in 55 matches across all competitions, tallying 10 goals and contributing three assists. Her performances have often come at crucial moments, demonstrating her value to the team.
Highlight Moments in Stengel’s Career
Stengel’s decisive goal in the 2025 NWSL quarterfinals against the favored Kansas City Current stood out as a defining moment. Scoring in stoppage time of extra time at CPKC Stadium, her strike propelled Gotham FC into the semifinals—tying her with the club record for playoff goals. Two years earlier, she also netted a long-range game-winner in the semifinal upset over the reigning champion Portland Thorns during the 107th minute of the playoff match.
Her professional journey spans 13 years across five countries, including stints in England with Crystal Palace and Liverpool, as well as four loan spells in Australia. Stengel’s accolades include a German league championship with Bayern Munich in 2015 and aiding Liverpool’s promotion to the English Women’s Super League (WSL) in 2022.
Looking Ahead: Stengel’s Role in Gotham’s Ambitions
By extending her commitment to Gotham FC, Katie Stengel strengthens the club’s roster with her experience and ability to perform in high-pressure situations. As the team pursues future successes in the NWSL, her leadership and proven track record will be critical assets. Fans and teammates alike will look to Stengel to continue delivering pivotal contributions as Gotham FC aims to build on its winning legacy.
