While many fans and analysts believe Aaron Rodgers is leaning toward resuming his role as the Pittsburgh Steelers’ starting quarterback in the 2026 season, nothing is guaranteed. Heading into the offseason, Rodgers’ intentions remain unclear, leaving the Steelers cautious about relying solely on his return. To avoid last year’s prolonged wait, the team aims to finalize plans before free agency begins on March 9, creating pressure for Rodgers to decide soon.
Given the absence of a signed contract, Pittsburgh is preparing alternate strategies, including pursuing veteran quarterbacks who will enter free agency as potential suits to lead the offense if Rodgers opts out or delays his decision.
Exploring Veterans Who Could Step In if Rodgers Does Not Return
Head coach Mike McCarthy has publicly expressed enthusiasm about rookie Will Howard, signaling confidence in the team’s young talent. Nevertheless, the Steelers recognize the value of securing an experienced quarterback to provide depth, compete for the starting job, or guide the offense if needed.
Joe Flacco as a Practical Option
Joe Flacco emerges as a practical, if unspectacular, candidate. Flacco has played for every AFC North team except the Steelers, recently completing a midseason transition from the Cleveland Browns to the Cincinnati Bengals. He plans to continue playing and will be a free agent this offseason. While not the marquee name the Steelers might hope for, Flacco’s experience and ability to compete with Howard offer a reliable fallback option.
Kirk Cousins: A Possible Budget-Friendly Choice
Kirk Cousins could become available after being a salary cap casualty for the Atlanta Falcons. Though Cousins secured a major contract only two years ago, his performance and value have declined, leading to free agency. Cousins has maintained a winning record in recent seasons, starting 30 games over the past two years, but has not delivered standout performances. Given his experience and affordability, he could fit the Steelers’ roster if Rodgers decides not to return.
Geno Smith Offers A Wildcard Option
Former Seattle Seahawks starter Geno Smith experienced a difficult period with the Las Vegas Raiders, who are expected to pursue rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza with a top 2026 NFL Draft selection. Smith will likely be released and available in free agency. His West Virginia roots add a local connection appealing to Pittsburgh. Although Smith is unlikely to match Rodgers’ caliber, he could compete for playing time and potentially provide unexpected value.
Implications and What to Expect Moving Forward
The Steelers find themselves balancing optimism about Aaron Rodgers’ return with realistic contingency planning. Should Rodgers commit to the team, Pittsburgh would continue to build around his veteran leadership. However, if Rodgers retires or delays, the franchise is prepared to pursue quarterbacks like Flacco, Cousins, or Smith to maintain competitiveness. These backup plans reflect Pittsburgh’s intent to avoid last year’s uncertainty and ensure the quarterback position remains secure as free agency approaches.
