Veteran quarterback Derek Carr has revealed that he would consider returning to the NFL in 2026, but only if he is in good health and joins a team with a legitimate chance to win the Super Bowl. With several teams searching for quarterbacks this offseason, Carr’s criteria significantly narrow down his potential landing spots.
Derek Carr’s Conditions for an NFL Comeback
On his recent podcast episode, Carr confirmed that he is open to making a comeback as a starting NFL quarterback. However, he emphasized that this decision hinges on two critical factors: his health and the competitiveness of the team interested in adding him.
“Would I do it? Absolutely, I would do it. I told you two things. I’d have to be healthy, and I would want a chance to win a Super Bowl. And obviously, that’s a tough thing to find. That’s hard to do.” – Derek Carr on a potential NFL return in 2026
Turning 35 this March, Carr played his last season in 2024 with the New Orleans Saints. He retired the following year, citing a reluctance to undergo surgery for a labral tear that had been causing persistent pain in his throwing shoulder. Nearly a year after stepping away from professional football, Carr remains open to returning, but only when the circumstances align with his goals.
Potential Teams That Could Match Carr’s Ambitions
Given Carr’s requirement for a Super Bowl-contending team, several franchises seem unlikely fits. Teams such as the Miami Dolphins, New York Jets, Cleveland Browns, and Arizona Cardinals are currently not realistic options. This leaves the Minnesota Vikings, Pittsburgh Steelers, Atlanta Falcons, and Indianapolis Colts as the more plausible destinations.
However, the Colts are expected to retain Daniel Jones, while Aaron Rodgers is widely anticipated to return to the Steelers for the upcoming season. That narrows Minnesota and Atlanta as the most viable candidates, both of which are reportedly seeking affordable veteran quarterbacks. Carr fits the profile financially but would need to demonstrate improvement from his recent performances to convince any team he can elevate their Super Bowl chances.
Challenges and Outlook for Carr’s Return
Despite Carr’s experience and availability, doubts linger about his ability to significantly boost a team’s championship prospects. His recent passing limitations raise questions about whether he can meet the high standards required for a successful Super Bowl run. As the 2026 NFL season approaches, his decision and potential landing spot will remain a topic of interest among fans and analysts.
The latest on a potential Derek Carr return to the NFL, from Derek himself 🗣️ https://t.co/BefLsxEbZk pic.twitter.com/y1HoCcjYLm
— Home Grown with David & Derek Carr (@HomeGrownTweet) February 12, 2026
